Web Zone81.com
  news
  trains
  auctions
  webmail
  dictionary
  jobs
  forums
  food
  web design
  contact
Zone81: English resources and information for gaijin in Japan

Does NHK have the right to charge you? Lawsuit eminent


Friday, July 26 2002, 16:45

KAWASAKI, Kanagawa - A man is threatening to sue Japanese TV network NHK on charges of misrepresentation and embezzlement.

Ken Barber, 24, an English teacher at a noted English school has lived in Japan for 4 years and claims to have never paid NHK.

"They are a fraud. Why are they owed money from me just because I have a TV? If they want to monitor who watches NHK they should scramble the station and make it pay per view. I never watch it and I will not pay for it."

NHK began as a government institution, but since then it has become a hazy issue as to whether all people in Japan with televisions are obligated to pay. This marks the first time in Japan anyone has ever challenged Japan's richest and most traditional network.

In most countries, public television operates on a donation-based system. Viewers are asked to donate, but not forced to pay or billed like NHK does.

"I told them that if I am obligated to pay, send the police to my house and arrest me. Or stop the services to me like the gas and water companies do. Of course they have no response, they have no legal grounds to charge anybody, that's why." Barber states.

NHK recently has gotten into trouble for staging fake documentaries and falsely threatening viewers to pay or face stiff penalties (penalties which have never been implemented).

"They don't even come to collect themselves, they send collectors. I asked through the inter-phone once, "do you work for NHK?" and he replied no."

Although the law is hazy, NHK indeed does not have the right to force people to pay because "they have televisions," and NHK is not part of the government. Which leads to the question of whether a private network can charge for their services in Japan. (Zone81.com)


Caesar's Commentary

I have lived in Japan for 12 years and not once have I paid NHK. Why? Because their programming stinks and because they do not have the right to charge me. I will be interested to see how this one turns out.

We all know that NHK fakes their documentaries, and that their little visits to our houses are not legal.

They have sent me bills, I guess they got tired of coming over, and up to now I think according to them I owe about 1,530,000 yen. For what? Having a TV? I don't think so.

I don't pay NHK, there is nothing they can do about it and none of you should pay them either.


Users Comments

Nigel
  Those NHK bastards come to my place about once a week! Is it legal for me to shoot them?
Dope
  Nigel - Japan law states that you may beat them, but not shoot them. :)
Sideshow Bob
  One of my students, a respectable middle aged woman, hasn't paid for 21 years. She must owe them a flippin' fortune
kimiko
  you guys should feel guilty. NHK provides a wonderful services and you should pay them for them
Drago
  NHK is the other group of Mafia in Japan, they forced people to pay for having TV.
west-side
  I pay them because the other station sux. NHK is better than any of them, apart from like movie channels.
CB
  Kimiko, I don't watch television. Why should I pay for it?
D.
  Once when they showed up to my place I just said "Take a look at my tv, I found it in the garbage, I never watch the thing and it doesn't even work right." Then I unplugged it from the wall, handed it to the guy and told him that since it was going to cost me so much for NHK he could just take the thing with him when he left. Needless to say, he didn't have a clue how to respond, handed me back the tv, and told me he'd have to check with his boss about what he was supposed to do and then come back. Definitely a good stalling technique.
Dope
  D. - that is a great story. I guarantee Japanese don't have the balls to treat them like that. I would never let one of those jack asses in my house though.
babs
  The guy (dork grunt grunt smoke smoke type) tried to bully me into paying. Ended the whole conversation with "biaaaaye biaaaaaye." SLAM (bab's door) REFUSE to pay! None of them have the balls to do jack!!
Bthumper
  I just treat them like they were poor lost souls, and ask them if they have accepted Jesus into their lives. I then let them know that for the low low price of 47.99 USD they can have their very own personal, blessed, coffee cup, replete with a certificate from one of the three popes, and that all of the nasty thoughts they have had about their 12 year old neighbors daughter have been forgiven. I think I have made enough off these guys to afford Satellite.
Dope
  Yes Jesus can now be yours for the low price of $19.99! Let's all pray...
Tam
  These pests used to give me a visit every month at my previous place. After I moved, I found a quick and easy solution that works great. Just tell the guys: "I don't own a TV" That was 2 years ago. Not a word from them since then.
Dope
  I tried that but they didn't believe me. Better solution, tell them "LEAVE ME THE HELL ALONE!" That works..
anpanman
  You guys are all so non-conformist. Don't you want to be a part of the hive mentality? C'mon, pay for buddha's sake.
AnthraxBuffet
  Here in Canada, I'd figure they should at least send one of their more attractive female "personalities" over to blow me before expecting me to pay anything for "sucky" programming!
Shery Mathew
  NHK sux... its just another screwed up channel. I havent seen thath bullshit channel and if ever those morons from NHK come... i will puke on their face..
Anti Shery
  Poda sherry,nee olathum o pinne
Anti shery
  Poda thadiya,melanagi pani cheyyu
sherys dad
  Hi this is sherys dad. I personally apologise to all,for the behaviour that my son sherys behaviour and the language he has been using. He has always been a pain in my #$%. He has this exceptional gift to be really creative with words and language. As many of you may not be in a place to appreciate it and may think of it as vulgur. However we have taken to view this as common and very normal behaviour on his part. Oh I forgot.... EndNote-NHK is indeed STUPID.
Sherys physcologist
  Ever since Shery was dumped by the Vice President of NHK[Male] he has been like this... It is just part of the rejction... so please be sympathetic to him for the language he has been using
Shery Mathew
  *** ascii decode error ***
Thalatherichu payan
  seems like only shery wants to end this problem. well, i will come to musashi urawa for that meeting.... guys come on.... we need to fight this together. we expect all ur active participation.
panajara kuttan
  shery is right... we need to end this some how. hey i am not sure if i will be able to make it this sunday, but count me in from next week onwards.
Babuchan
  hi guys seems like this topic is really getting outta control. shery do we really need to go for such extreme measures. wat if they put us behind bars !!! anyway i will be there this sunday but i will keep a distance and check out wats happening. cud u tell me how to get to musashi urawa ?
Shery Mathew
  good to know that we have some like minded people in here. Hey Babuchan, our rights have been abused and we are only protesting the same. There is nothing wrong in it. Besides the jails here are better ... they give much better food. if they put us behind bars, i mite ask them to extend the stay for another day or two.
jatti vasu
  kudos to the group... i have been staying here in japan for a long time and i am seeing this kind of anger for the first time. I too feel NHK sux. I have never watched the channel at all and how dare they ask me for cash. Musashi urawa is quite far... hey shery how abt changing the venue every week. keep us posted abt this sunday's events. i will get a bunch of guys from here.
Madhura painnkilli
  Hi guys grt going guys...lets burn those suckers...luv u guys for taking the initiative
kimiko
  r u some kinda clowns? u will be behind bars without bail
Maatupetti Machaan
  In fact we should be going to the NHK office and asking them for money...because they make us watch all these mind mnumbing gameshows and serials...it iw us that has to be paid
Bellbottom Jayan
  edaa kimiko .. NHK innu cash koduthaal ende molle kettipikkan ulla cash ninde appan therumodaaa,pattii!!!!
Anil Gafoor
  But i am ready to pay for NHK provided they air some kambi on weekends. I ll no way benifit from it but but restless brothers will get some solace. I am very very happy with my surya tv. btw i am sherrys GYM mate.
Anil Gafoor
  But i am ready to pay for NHK provided they air some kambi on weekends. I ll no way benifit from it but but restless brothers will get some solace. I am very very happy with my surya tv. btw i am sherrys GYM mate.
UniversalGodd
  "NHK" is "Naked Hong Kong"--like that "Naked News" program, right?
NickKyobashi
  Undbelievable.I told those NHK to piss off.The guy replied'Its a Japanse rule'.I shouldnt have opened the bloody door.Now they know there is a kechi Gaijin in my appartment block.They will come in droves now.Ohhhh man.Ive read all your mails.So there is no way they can prosecute me right?
Dork
  They just came to my place today. I've never paid before and I ain't gonna pay this time either.
jcservant
  I'm a Christian, how do I handle this, its very complexing for me, any suggestions?
Arif
  *** ascii decode error ***
Khandakar
  Can you say what dose it mean? Article 32 of the Broadcast Law Any person who has installed receiving equipment capable of receiving the broadcasting provided by NHK shall conclude a contract with NHK with regard to the reception of its broadcasting. However, this shall not apply to those who have installed receiving equipment not intended for the reception of broadcasting, or receiving equipment solely for the reception of radio broadcasting or multiplex broadcasting (broadcasting of voice and other sound transmissions not coming under television broadcasting and multiplex broadcasting classifications). http://www.nhk.or.jp/english/index.html
stella
  some time later..... it seems we have a little cultural clash here. may I ask, where u guys who make such a fuzz about NHK fees come from?
scott wallace
  Stop complaining. You americans only want popular trash. But not everyone want to watch the most popular shows. some people want to watch cultural tv.educational shows. Oh and for those who are uneducated about public tv the BBC operates the same system as NHK.And the BBC is definatly world renowned. No sponsership, no advertising, just TV license, and government funding. but then again, not many american llook outside of FOX or CNN let alone their borders. Maybe you think NHK is rubbish because you cant speak japanese. Oh and lets not remember the rubbish that come out from the US tv channels and with a commercial every 5 minutes nowbody wants to watch it. It seems that you are unaware of european TV pay system and how the NHK system is the same as the UK system. I hope this puts it right.
Freeeedoooooomm!!!!
  it seems scotty wallace is going through is periodic roid rage.




English auctions in Japan   Japan trains   Japan jobs     Web Forum   Web Design   Free webmail